Tony Pryce started his interest in the Armstrong murder case back when he was an officer with West Mercian Police, and he had to visit a local solicitor's office in Hereford. The firm was TA Matthews, and in a glass case there was a pipe and a letter. The pipe had belonged to Major Armstrong, and the letter was to thank the original TA Matthews for all his help during the Major's trial and appeal process.
Since then, he's gone into incredible detail on every aspect of the case, including every person involved and their family backgrounds, and how they related to each other. He believes the evidence is overwhelming that Major Armstrong was guilty.
One interesting detail is that some evidence from the case ended up in the Metropolitan Police Museum. Back in 1921, when a murder investigation needed to be done, small police forces often didn't have the expertise to carry them out, so they applied to the Metropolitan Police to send experienced officers. Modern day investigations typically involve 26 police officers and 4 support staff - back then the Met sent a Detective Chief Inspector (this was his last case before retirement) and a Detective Sergeant, and they started their investigations in secret, while staying at the Green Dragon Hotel in Hereford.
So there is a packet in the Black Museum labelled as arsenic from the chemist at Hay - but it has never been analysed. Tony Pryce tried to persuade them to find out what the white powder was, but when they realised that the objective was to prove Major Armstrong's guilt rather than overturn the guilty verdict, they decided it wasn't worth spending the money to do it. Tony Pryce believes that the packet was planted in the Major's bureau (which was produced as a surprise exhibit during the court case) by a member of the defence team, because he owed Major Armstrong a favour. It's a fascinating theory, and very convincing.
There were so many fascinating details like this that the talk ran for an hour and a half instead of an hour, and he could have continued. However, he got as far as the execution at Gloucester Prison (an ex-prison governor now gives guided tours of the building!) and stopped there.
Cusop Village Hall was so full they ran out of chairs and had people standing at the back and into the entrance hall! And there wasn't time to show the video advert for the Cusop Castle dig, which will be happening from 5th to 14th June this year. Also, I'll be giving a talk on Saturday 9th May at Cusop Castle at 4pm on medieval weapons and arrows, hopefully with audience participation!