Well, the answer is: it's complicated.
Last night at the Globe there was a packed house for a film followed by Q&A session with some local food producers - a vegan gardener, Juliette from Shepherds Ice Cream, the lady from Wobbly Owl and the chap from Primrose Farm. The lady from the new bookshop The Kitchen Shelf was also there with a selection of her cookbooks. (sorry about how terrible I am at remembering names!)
The film was a documentary by James Wong, who is an ethnobotanist based in Singapore. He went all round the world interviewing people from small farmers in Uganda to a chap from Unilever, to talk about climate change and how farmers can try to adapt to the new conditions. I particularly liked the chap in the Bronx in New York, pointing across to the Manhattan skyline and saying that it was the biggest food hub in the world, but only a mile away where he was standing was a food desert. He was doing his best to change that by growing food on waste ground and handing out bags of groceries to local people.
The film got a generally good reception, though the chap from Primrose Farm expressed some doubt. "Does he really think Unilever will save us?"
There was a good discussion about what counted as local - Shepherd's Ice Cream uses local sheep's milk (now from Vowchurch though it was from Stratford-upon-Avon for a while after they stopped milking their own sheep), and most of the fruit they add comes from Herefordshire - but not things like lemon, or chocolate.
Primrose farm depends on the WWOOF volunteers to run the farm, and Ty Madoc cider has had vastly different growing seasons - a bumper crop (but with less sugar than expected in the apples) one year, and only 20% of that the next year! And they're not sure whether they'd be able to be a viable business without the shop in Hay, which depends on tourists in the summer season.
It's not only difficult for the small producers - Debbie from Londis was in the audience, and talked about how much harder it was to run the shop now than it had been when they took over 18 years ago. She added that they've stopped selling bananas altogether now, because the Co-op over-orders them, and then gives what's left to Zero Waste, so people are getting bananas for free.
On the face of it, Zero Waste is a really good idea, because it makes sure that food that would otherwise go to landfill gets eaten instead - but in this case it's just one more example of how the supermarkets swamp the market and drive out the little local shops. Everyone on the panel agreed that the supermarkets have a stranglehold on food sales in the UK, and it's very difficult for small local producers to keep going.
Another problem is procurement by, for instance, local authorities for schools. They have financial pressures to choose the cheapest and easiest option, rather than the producers on their doorstep. One scheme in Manchester was mentioned, where the person running it proved that it was actually cheaper to buy dirty carrots and pay someone to chop them up than it was to buy pre-packaged sliced carrots as the schools had been doing. The flyer given out at the event mentioned that only 6% of the vegetables served at Welsh schools had been grown in Wales (source BBC Wales), and it must be possible to change that at local authority level.
Another lady talked about a local charity which had been working with the kids at Talgarth School, growing food and learning how to cook it and eat it - but their budget was cut.
Someone else asked how all these small initiatives can find out about each other - it would be great for there to be more communication between these schemes so they can work together and share information.
Mike Eccles was also in the audience, and he's just come back from a Farming Conference which he said was very interesting. He is working to set up an online local "supermarket" with food from local farmers, amongst other things, as part of the Hay Resilience CIC. They are having their Christmas Party and fundraiser at the Globe on Thursday 10th December from 7pm, with the Climate Choir and the Bog Beans providing live music.
The flyers provided by Botany and Other Stories had some worrying statistics about self-sufficiency in food in the UK. The UK has not been self-sufficient in food for many years, but the percentage has gone down from 80% in the 1980s to 60% now, and the supply network is complex and vulnerable to failure - as we saw during Covid with empty supermarket shelves for a variety of products.
It might not be a case of us choosing to eat locally and give up coffee or chocolate as much as climate change forcing it on us, because extreme weather globally was also touched on in James Wong's documentary, with fire, flood and drought affecting farmers' yields.
Botany and Other Stories are planning a follow up event on Saturday 30th January, again at the Globe from 7pm, with the screening of a film followed by a Q&A session with a panel of scientists, and on Saturday 20th February they are holding an event called Bring Your Mug! at the Buttermarket during the day, for the benefit of Brecon Food Bank (I believe soup will be involved!)
And finally, there was the raffle in aid of Brecon Food Bank. I won a hamper!!! I never usually win anything!

